Monday, October 8, 2012

Thundergod: The Ascendance of Indra - Book Review


                Rajiv G Menon’s debut novel, ‘Thundergod : The Ascendance of Indra’ is a bout of relief amidst the various attempts at handling mythology by his contemporaries. While the plot draws a sigh out of you; yet another story based on yet another character out of Indian mythology. The neat narration that doesn’t lose pace (or gore for that matter) has you hooked until the end. The language is clean, save for a few bumps that I shall talk about in a minute.

                The book details the birth and rise of Indra as the king of Devas and in time, ascend to being god of thunder. What begins as a journey of vengeance, takes him through his self as a barbarian who works to become king, then the ultimate warrior, leader of brother tribes, slayer of evil and eventually graduate as a god, literally relocating to heaven, so he could keep a protective watch over lesser mortals.

                This journey as you can imagine, is not easy. Why and how Indra tackles life and his destiny is what the novel attempts to convey. Proceeding to the dissection :

Warning : This review contains spoilers. You might want to read the book first, if you don't wish to know them beforehand.

What worked for me:
1. The plot, events and narration in general. One thing leads to another naturally and the author takes us through in a logical pace.

2. Short chapters that makes it easy to navigate.

3. Subtle humour that runs along, without getting cocky.

4. I liked the names of Indra’s friends; the fact that they happen to be named so and acquire their powers only later on. The author plays a clever hand here.

What did not work for me:
1. Inspite of an interesting plotline and good narration, this book can actually be summarized in one equation : Sex + War (Die Hard style). If someone isn’t cutting someone else’s head off, or disemboweling an army, they are jumping into each others’ arms.
                  *  There are women of all sorts – goddesses, slaves, wives and friends, using sex as the only weapon to either humiliate Indra & Co or to supposedly attempt to defeat them. At one point it just got plainly queasy and felt like the author had run out of imagination. Granted, our ancestors lived literally like animals but detailed explanations everytime and the frequency only made the author sound like an ancient version of E.L.James.
                 *  If you held the book sideways and squeezed it hard, you could most definitely collect a bucket of blood and gory body parts. Ruthless killing in the name of war happens page after page. No wonder history is so violent! Be warned of possible nightmares if you sit on this one late.

2. There are atleast a hundred names in here. And a few hundred more for animals and weapons even. They all end up sounding very very alike, and sometimes even gender-neutral. I had a tough time placing Ur-Uruk and Ugra. Wait, did I get it right?

3. The war sequences are presented in excruciating detail. While watching it on screen would be easy on your imagination, reading about it line by line, grows tedious after a hundred pages.  Those sequences could have been trimmed. And, the mission of Indra, describes the need  to unite the sons of Aditi. Sadly, you have to dig that act up amidst descriptions of a hundred other battles.

4. The blurb wonders whether Indra would ever get the one woman he loves, to love him back again. There is no description of any such attempt in the book. She hates him after a terrible incident and that's it. They drift apart. Later he comes to know she considers him dead and he just let's her go. For someone he claimed as his true love, this was simply lack of effort and interest. Why?

5. The biggest thorn in this books fictional flesh, is the phrase ‘Unlike the world had ever seen’. Take my word for it when I say, that phrase appears atleast 675 times in this book. I admit, the number is exaggerated, but that is how magnificently annoying it was. It reminded me of Harold Bloom’s review of Harry Potter, where he claims JKR had over used the phrase ‘Stretched his legs’. One more occurrence and the book could have been renamed. Thundergod –Unlike the world had ever seen!

Verdict:
Thundergod is a good and interesting narrative. It guarantees a read that will take you from cover to cover, having to make only a few pitstops enroute. Definitely commendable for a debut.  Pick it up when you are in the mood for a history lesson that holds the promise of a roller coaster ride.

Rating : 3.5/5


Image courtesy : Flipkart.com

P.S : Incase you are wondering how I was able to review the book when it is due for release only later this month - Abracadabra! Read below :)

This review is a part of the Book Reviews Program at BlogAdda.com. Participate now to get free books!

Did you like this review? Do you agree with the points expressed? Or not? Drop in a comment. Let's discuss  :)


3 comments:

  1. ok so the narrative was good and everything seemed logical, I like the way the writer blended different mythologies-Gaia(Greek), Ishtar(Mesopotamian)and other Indain myths ...but I thing really bothered me!... They say it takes a life time of virtue and good karma to enter heaven... and to that heaven a bunch of Barbaric, women-molesters, brutes and idiots are appointed as gods...what the hell!!...these people don't even deserve a place in Hell.

    "...There is no place here for emotions like anger, jealousy and hatred, hence no need for weapons or wars" (Page 376)
    Are you kidding me!! these Devas are practically originated out of these elements. It seems so unfair...other good people have to work their way through Penance to enter heaven and these brutes get a free pass and are glorified!...It would be better if they were drafted as super humans whom ordinary people considered as gods.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi. I wonder how I missed your comment all along! :O And you are absolutely right. This fact disturbed me as well. It seemed like the only qualification someone needed to find honor and in this case godly status is to kill and kill ruthlessly. Makes me wonder if they had even the least sense to learn from their ancestors. I think the term 'god' in mythology has always been used to denote someone who has done things that had phenomenal consequences. When and why it turned into something supernatural, I guess we'll never find out! I'm glad though that people are finally beginning to reason openly about these concepts. Thanks for dropping by :)

      Delete
    2. Thank you for finally replying... :) .. Any idea when is the 2nd part of this series coming ?

      Delete